In
Dingo alpha4 “full” build (Jan 5), I changed from cdrkit to cdrtools (I
don’t recall if I had already made the changeover in barebones alpha4).
Anyway, there was a typo which caused the cdrtools package to be left
out of the build. Result, neither cdrkit or cdrtools is in the build.
No wonder multisession doesn’t work. Burning of any kind won’t work.
So, I put in cdrtools, tested multisession, and yes, it did save the
session, but did so incorrectly. The command is something like this,
simplified here:
growisofs -M /dev/sr0 -D -R -quiet -graft-points 2008-1-8-11-22=/initrd/pup_rw
This is supposed to create a folder on the DVD named
‘2008-1-8-11-22′ with the saved session in it, but instead the session
got saved at ‘/’.
Well, growisofs is a frontend for mkisofs, the latter being a
utility in cdrtools. So, that’s where the buck stops. Those who have
followed my blog for sometime may recall earlier grumbles about
mkisofs. Puppy 3.01 has cdrtools version 2.01.01a23 but the mkisofs
utility did not work at all, just exited with “unknown error”. So I
made up a hybrid package for 3.01, named
‘cdrtools-2.01.01a23-mkisofs_01a10, which has mkisofs from cdrtools
2.01.01a10.
Now at cdrtools version 2.01.01a36, we have a mkisofs that does
something, no error message, the only problem being that it does the
wrong thing.
So, I went back to cdrkit (v1.1.6), the Debian fork of cdrtools, and
this time the session saved nicely in a subdirectory on the DVD just
like it is supposed to. Rebooted, the saved session reloaded just like
it is supposed to.
Then I saved a second session, rebooted, but this time got the
“cannot find pup_395.sfs” message and got dropped to a shell in the
initramsf. I tried ‘mount -t iso9660 /dev/sr0 /mnt/data’ and got a
“failed” message.
I took the DVD to my laptop and mounted it with Pmount, no problem, and there are the two saved sessions, as expected.
So, this is a “progress” report. At this point in time I’m mystified
why the DVD won’t mount while in the initramfs. I need to rest now,
will continue trying to solve this mystery later.
January 11th, 2008 at 11:47 pm
There is good news and bad news!
IDE HD is now visible, the PUI works and the GRUB installer works (although the curious tray opening is back with a new feature - it stays open!).
And now for the bad news.
The boot up looping is back. Sorry - I can’t remember the answer and probably wouldn’t understand it either.
Cfdisk is still dead in the water.
January 12th, 2008 at 12:50 am
It gets worse. The wrong menu.lst is written - it alludes to fd0 after the opening lines when only the HD should be listed. Although there seems to be confusion between hda & sda, editing these does not stop the looping - the problem may not be in menu.lst?
January 12th, 2008 at 9:26 am
Barry,
I confirm, multisession CD / DVD now is working on Puppy Dingo alpha 5.
I load the iso first time, no problem.
I make internet setup, saving on my DVD +RW , all went OK.
I reboot and all setings and saved appears in the second boot.
I make additional setings , adding firefox, transmission, linuxrar, and others. Saving again on DVD +RW.
I reboot and puppy Dingo alpha 5 load the 2 Directories saved and all went OK.
Bravo. We will have puppy forever.
January 12th, 2008 at 2:00 pm
Sadly, there is more - can’t ’see’ other new installed distros which use kernel 2.6.23 on IDE with Dingo, but no problems with v3.01.
January 12th, 2008 at 6:02 pm
JustGreg has started a forum thread for feedback on alpha5:
http://www.murga-linux.com/puppy/viewtopic.php?t=25348
January 12th, 2008 at 7:43 pm
Barry: If you prefer to receive all comments via John’s Forum when you announce important changes/revisions/etc it might be advantageous for you yourself to start a new thread? Being under your own name, everyone would then know that it was kosher and would receive your attention.
January 12th, 2008 at 9:03 pm
Sage; that’s a really good idea.
I for one have been confused as to just where to post what.
To complete “the set” as it were, a thread for suggestions/comments specific to the release in addition to one dedicated to bugs might be handy.
January 13th, 2008 at 7:28 pm
Barry, Thank you generally for your dedication and efforts at Making Puppy all that it can be. Also, Ditto as to agreeing with Sage and nic2109 as to just where to post suggestions/comments for both confirmation of success or as to bugs new or confirmed. I for one have remained silent for many months because of this confusion!